"[2] Tony Cummings of Cross Rhythms rated the album a perfect ten squares, remarking how this release "is quite simply a classic and the first three tracks alone will surely produce huge radio exposure and international popularity.

"[7] Andrew Funderburk of CM Addict rated the album four out of five stars, writing that "Despite being light, there is a strength that exudes from each word sung" on the release.

[4] At 365 Days of Inspiring Media, Joshua Andre rated the album four stars out of five, writing how "it's clear that Rend Collective bring so much lyrical and musical creativity throughout these 13 tracks, injecting fun, joy and life into worship.

"[3] Timothy Yap of Hallels gave a positive review, saying that "And all we hear are the raw and haunting vocals of Gareth Gilkeson worshipping; here you know you have entered God's Holy presence.

"[12] At Alpha Omega News, Rob Snyder graded the album an A−, writing that "The biggest clue as to what The Art of Celebration sounds like is in the title.