It stars John Leguizamo, Katherine Waterston and Cynthia Nixon, with Andy Comeau and Denis O'Hare.

In voice over, Shirley Lyner (Waterston) introduces her babysitting service, a cabin with middle-aged men and teenage girls.

A flashback takes us to Shirley being picked up by Michael Beltran (Leguizamo) for a babysitting job.

When Michael is driving Shirley home that night, they stop at the train yard and explore it, eventually sharing a kiss.

Melissa (Lauren Birkell) discovers the truth about babysitting outings from Shirley and Michael tells Jerry about it.

Problems arise when Brenda invites her rough and aggressive younger stepsister Nadine (Halley Wegryn Gross) into the group without checking with Shirley.

Shirley then tells Nadine to stop going behind her back and doing business without her permission and that she gets twenty percent of all their cuts.

Melissa presents Shirley with fake permission slips for a trip to Jerry's cabin for a weekend.

With Nadine almost falling off, Jerry pulls her back after beating up the man in the vehicle.

The website's critics consensus reads: "Though built on an audacious and controversial premise, Babysitters teeters between exploitation and grossness due to uneven execution.