"[2] Mary Nikkel, indicating in a four and a half star review by New Release Today, replies, "The Burning Edge of Dawn holds easily the strongest, most grace-drenched songwriting you will hear this year.

"[5] Graham Gladstone, rating the album four and a half stars from Worship Leader, writes, "The Burning Edge of Dawn is a solid release, aching with authenticity, and is poised not just to please musical ears but to encourage the souls of those who seek God in a world with no easy answers.

"[4] Ryan Barbee, specifying in a four star review from Jesus Freak Hideout, responds, "the album took some time to fully process, but once it reached a point of understanding, it made a solid landing.

"[7] Allocating a four and a half star review for the album by The Christian Beat, Sarah Baylor regards, "Each song is so unique and Peterson shares such beautiful stories through his masterfully crafted lyrics.

"[12] Assigning the album four and a half stars at 366 Days of Inspiring Media, Jonathan Andre writes, "Andrew’s follow-up to his greatest hits project is nothing less of magnificent.