Todd Mohney of Rise Against played guitar on the 2004 God Don't Make No Trash or Up Your Ass with Broken Glass EP but could not attend the recording session for the band's first full length Unicornography,[1] and his spot was temporarily filled in by Kelly and Hennessy prior to Hause appearing on Gather Up The Chaps.

Specifically, he cited Andriano's role in Alkaline Trio as making the bass player's availability for touring limited.

In December 2004, the band released the EP God Don't Make No Trash -or- Up Your Ass With Broken Glass.

The album also features re-recorded versions of the songs "I'm So Happy I Could Just Cry Myself to Sleep -or- The Routes We Wander" and "Building the Perfect Asshole Parade -or- Scratching Off the Fleas", both of which were originally featured on the band's 2004 God Don't Make No Trash or Up Your Ass with Broken Glass EP.

[2] At an intimate show at the borderline in London on July 7, 2012, Brendan Kelly and Dan Andriano admitted Sam Russo into the band as touring guitarist and backing vocalist.