The stores are in Wyncote, Upper Darby, Brookhaven, and Monument Avenue in Philadelphia.

[6] Since 2001, the University of Pennsylvania made efforts to remove The Fresh Grocer from its Walnut Street location.

The grocery store sued University of Pennsylvania maintaining its intention to stay at the location.

[11] In 2024, The Fresh Grocer announced its entrance into New York through the opening of a new location in Oakdale at the Lighthouse Commons shopping center on Montauk Highway, formerly home to a Best Market.

The store, owned and operated by the Thompson family, spans 26,000 square feet.