At Cross Rhythms, Stephen Curry told that the "Lead singer Jeremiah Carlson has a distinctive tone which complements the band's southern US rock music approach which is not unlike Third Day.

"[2] Andrea Hunter of Worship Leader stated that the release was "An amalgam of classic, alt and modern rock, with country, roots, and pop inflections—electric and acoustic—are the backdrop for lead singer Jeremiah’s Carlson’s evocative vocals and passionate songwriting.

"[3] In addition, Hunter said that "With a solid scriptural foundation and unrelenting passion—huge, dynamic, yet sensitive and fluid, reminiscent of Kings of Leon, yet completely in the now—The Neverclaim delivers a release with a youth vibe that is equally suited for church, times of private worship, concert halls, and arenas.

[4] At New Release Tuesday, Kevin Davis wrote that "If you've been desperately waiting for a fresh filling of The Holy Spirit-led worship that is truly unashamed of the Gospel of Jesus Christ, then don't miss out on this incredible album, one of the best of the year for sure.

"[5] Jay Heilman at Christian Music Review noted that "The energy and message that permeates this album is obvious – one that I believe will resonate in the hearts of listeners and encourage them to line their walks up with that of Christ, the One who we should observe above all else.

"[8] Mark Geil of Jesus Freak Hideout wrote that "The production by Paul Moak [...] and Jason Ingram [...], is solid, and the album fits nicely in the collection of fans of Third Day and Needtobreathe.

"[9] Furthermore, Jesus Freak Hideout's Bert Gangl told that "Rather than trying desperately to combine their divergent musical influences into some sort of coherent whole, they and their bandmates have wisely opted to start from scratch for the self-titled national freshman effort.