Melinda Hill of AllMusic begins her review with, "The Pieces Fit, Pearl Barrett and Jeanette Herdman's first effort at continuing the duo Considering Lily, isn't a total failure.

"[1] Michael Ehret of the Daily Vault concludes his review with, "This disc is fun.

"[3] Jenn Terry wrote a review for Jesus Freak Hideout and gives the album 2½ stars out of a possible 5.

She starts the review with, "From the first song "Great Expectations," I felt as if I was stuck on a spaceship headed to a place where all they used to play music were drum machines and modern electronics.

"[4] 1 – "Great Expectations" 2 – "Today" 3 – "What I Was Made For" 4 – "Whisper" 5 – "Complete Me" 6 – "Waiting For The Day" 7 – "Electric" 8 – "Great Big God" 9 – "Come Rescue Me" 10 – "I Want To Need To Know You" 11 – "Put Me In The Picture" 12 – "The Pieces Fit" Track information and credits adapted from Discogs[5] and AllMusic.