[2] Christopher Smith, rating the album three stars from Jesus Freak Hideout, states, "The Remixes has a respectable spread of dance tunes and creative tracks, but the safe and clumsy songs make this a less valuable purchase.

"[8] In a three star review, Andrew Funderburk of CM Addict says, "It is still fun and creative at its respective points, but ultimately it doesn’t live up to the potential that it could have had.

"[4] Awarding the album five stars for Christian Review Magazine, Leah St. John states, "The Remixes is a replay-worthy collection of awesome tracks.

"[3] Indicating in a four-star review at 365 Days of Inspiring Media, Micah Garnett describes only one "minor gripe on an otherwise outstanding remix album."

Reggie Edwards, writing for The Front Row Report, rating the album eight stars out of ten, says, "While The Remixes doesn't offer up any original song material, you get the feeling of listening to an all-new record.