[6] Dustin (Jansen Panettiere), Albert (Frankie Ryan Manriquez) and Mark (Allen Isaacson) are 12-year-old friends looking forward to Summer fun in 1970.

Throughout the summer, many other boys in the neighborhood get involved in the Bible study, including Nick, who, after a couple of encounters with Mr. Sperry, becomes remorseful and turns from his bullying ways.

The soundtrack, composed by Jasper Randall, won Best Original Score in the 2009 San Antonio Independent Christian Film Festival.

[11] Randall Christy of the Gospel Station Network stated the film was number one at the Ada, Oklahoma box office over the November 6–8, 2009 weekend.

[12] Christian actor Kirk Cameron said, "The Secrets of Jonathan Sperry moved me with its message of eternity and how one faithful man can make a difference in the lives of many.

"[13] Common Sense Media gave the film only two out of five stars, citing its "very thin story," "heartfelt but amateurish performances by the young actors," and being "male-driven, and with one notable exception, white and Christian."

"[14] The Independent Critic rated the movie at 3 stars, commending Christiano for assembling "a fine looking and well acted production that is both intelligently crafted and sensitively written."