Business in the mall was hurt in 1985 due to a weeks-long strike by Laneco employees.

[7] The next major change occurred in 1988, when A&P switched banners into a Super Fresh grocery store.

Super Fresh later closed in 1993 due to "extremely poor sales" that were attributed to competition from a much newer and larger Redner's Warehouse Market that had opened down the street in 1990.

[9][10] By 1995, the Lane department store at Trexler Mall had closed, leaving Bon-Ton as the only anchor tenant.

In 2011, Giant supermarket left the Shoppes at Trexler to open a new facility adjacent to the former mall.