Picking up exactly where "Unwindulax" left off, Jack and Liz have each realized that the 2012 Presidential election will be decided by a group of Northern Florida voters who are devoted fans of Jenna Maroney's latest single, "Catching Crabs in Paradise."
Jack wins the debate by not focusing on the issues, but rather by pointing out that Jenna will be the coolest celebrity in the Republican Party.
Utilizing Tracy's penchant for making horrible jokes about recently deceased celebrities, Liz logs him into Jenna's Twitter account and sets him loose.
However, he discovers that the girl has become inspired by Jenna's success, hoping to skip business school and get implants.
He claims to be genuinely invested in the outcome, but it is clear he is really attempting to recreate the moment of Obama's election.
Pete grows increasingly desperate, even attempting to get Brian Williams to call the election early.
In a third subplot, Kenneth receives his absentee ballot from his hometown and is thrilled to be voting for the first time.
Amy Amatangelo of Paste magazine gave the episode a 7.9 out of 10 and praised the Liz/Jack dynamic, but was critical of the plot's main focus on Jenna.