This second library kept the same $1 membership fee until 1895, when it was discounted to half the price in an effort to grow its customer base.
This library operated until 1983 and was replaced by the current location attached to Chestnut Hall.
[2] In 2012, Chestnut Hall was assessed by a historical society that determined it was "badly showing its age" and may also be at risk of a fire due to damaged wiring.
[3] In 2020, Thorold's city council considered creating an additional branch to the Canada Games Park but ultimately decided against it due to plans to expand the current building.
[4] In 2022, the library stopped issuing fines to patrons in order to improve access for those experiencing financial difficulties.