Originally from Brisbane, Queensland, Pincus is a Gold Coast native and moved to Sydney, New South Wales to play rugby in 2016.

However, Pincus' team lost in the final 21–14 to ERC Borneo Eagles.

In May 2017, Pincus signed for the Jersey Reds of the English RFU Championship.

[2][3] In mid-2018 Pincus, along with fellow Australian and Wallaby great, George Smith, signed for newly-promoted team the Bristol Bears of the Premiership.

[4][5][6] In February 2020 Pincus was signed by Super Rugby side Melbourne Rebels with immediate effect.