At the time of its closure, the stadium had a capacity of 6,023; it was demolished in 2018, and is now the site of the Ark Pioneer Academy, which opened in 2019.

Barnet played their final game at the stadium on 20 April 2013 with a 1–0 win over Wycombe Wanderers, with Jake Hyde scoring the winner in the 81st minute, and Graham Stack saving a 94th-minute penalty to secure the victory in front of a sell-out crowd of 6,001.

[7] Edgware Town played their opening games of the 2014–15 Spartan South Midlands League season at Underhill, while their Silver Jubilee Park ground was refurbished.

[9] Demolition work began in January 2018 to facilitate the building of the Ark Pioneer Academy, which opened in September 2019.

[10] Barnet opened the 1,016 seater South Stand in 2008 to replace the temporary structure which had stood in its place for over ten years.

The stand was first used for the FA Cup victory over Swindon Town in January 2008, just a matter of weeks after work had started.

The club announced that work was underway in order to erect four corner floodlights, to be 25 metres high and have a 500 Lux value as opposed to the previous 350.

Work was completed prior to the opening pre-season game of the 2010–2011 season against Arsenal and the stadium capacity was again increased to 6,023 as a result.

After a matchday incident on the East Terrace, the club acted to increase the distance between home and away supporters.