A new building was erected in 1889 with plans prepared by Melbourne architect William Edward Robertson, the construction was supervised by James Wright.

The ground floor of the brick building had a large banking chamber, a manager's office, strongroom, entrance hall, dining room and kitchen.

[1] In 1931 the property was purchased by the Church of England for the Flying Angel Mission to Seamen organisation.

In December 1937 plans were approved for the construction of the St Andrew's Mariners Chapel to the west (along High Street) behind the former bank building.

Information from the City of Fremantle Interpretation Plaques and Panels Research Project was used as the basis of this article.