[4] The band's sophomore album, All of Them Naturals, was released on 3 November 2016 on Static Shock Records and Fashionable Idiots, led by the single Who Made The Man?

[5][6] Describing the album as a work from "one of contemporary punk's most creative bands", Exclaim praised its "bizarre musical and lyrical ideas".

[7] Pitchfork considered the album's "twitchy neurosis" and "sardonic" humor to bridge a line between being "self-aware" and "aggressively obtuse".

Club praised the album's "jagged punk with a satirical edge", stating it found the band "sprawling out while building new alcoves in their weirdo mythology".

[16][17][18][19] Similar to DEVO, the band employs narrative elements in the concept and packaging of their music, including the operations of the titular Club and the fictional National Pen Company and Sunbelt Chemical Corporation.