In 2012 Crawley moved from England to Babson Park, Florida to join the bowling program at Webber International University.
[citation needed] She made another bid for her first title at the 2018 PWBA Sonoma County Open, only to lose a high-scoring championship match by two pins to Shannon O'Keefe, 268–266.
[7] At the 2019 Twin Cities Open, Crawley defeated Maria Jose Rodriguez and Bryanna Cote, but fell seven pins short to O'Keefe in the title match.
[12] As a 2023 title winner, Crawley gained automatic entry into the season-ending PWBA Tour Championship, where she earned the #5 seed for the televised finals after 24 games of qualifying.
She lost the opening match in the finals, tying #4 seed Erin McCarthy, 268–268 after the standard ten frames, only to lose a one-ball roll-off, 10–6.
In her opening match against Crystal Elliott, Crawley rolled the first 11 strikes, but was denied a perfect game when she got a seven-count on her final shot for a 297 score.