[3][4] Ice cream, made from a coconut and/or cashew base,[5][6] is available as a sandwich, scoop, sundae, or waffle cone, or as affogato.

The drink menu includes beers, ciders, cold brew, kombucha, and wines.

[12] Waz Wu included the pizzeria in the website's 2021 overview of "Where to Find Knockout Vegan Pizza in Portland".

[13] Alex Frane included the restaurant in Thrillist's 2020 list of "The Absolute Best Pizza in Portland".

[14] Vancouver Magazine included Virtuous Pie in a 2021 list of the city's best vegetarian restaurants.