Behrendt originally created the opening theme, “Estoy Podcuddle,” under the name HoboTang,[3] and most of the music played on the show is performed by his band, The Reigning Monarchs.

They began recording Walking the Room in Behrendt's bedroom for the first 10 episodes, then relocated to the now-trademark closet to improve the show's sound quality.

[12] The most notable recurring storylines involved the chronicles of Anthony's neighborhood, but topics ranged from comedy and show business (like a story about Dane Cook casually trying to steal one of Behrendt's classic bits),[13] to family life, prison and candy (particularly Australian biscuits, Tim Tams).

Walking the Room labelled itself a "podcuddle," and its hardcore fans, known as “Cuddlahs” (or “Customers”), were described as “Clown from the Neck Down.” The show built upon itself more than most podcasts, which can be attributed to their ever-evolving real-life cliffhangers, as well as the podcuddle-specific language they continually generated.

[14] The show's official website, designed by Damien Schaefer and launched on April 17, 2011, provides a glossary, written by Vicky Pezza, to help new listeners navigate the dialogue.

[18] Additionally, crossovers with Walking the Room’s sister podcast, TOFOP (formerly Thirty Odd Foot of Pod), hosted by comedian Wil Anderson and actor Charlie Clausen, helped the show gain a following in their native country of Australia.