The roster included brothers Shorty & Wilfred Veno, Irving Small, Ag Smith, Herb Rhéaume, Dinty Moore, Normand Shay, and Phil Rudolph.

Club president Emile Conlon publicly refuted rumors that the team's Canadian players were ineligible to play in the USAHA.

The Westminsters defeated Pere Marquette 4–3 in double overtime, beat the Boston Athletic Association 2–1, and shutout the Melrose Hockey Club 4–0 to secure a spot in the league.

[15] Munro instead former a team with junior and industrial league players known as the Toronto Invaders that lost two games to the Westminster Hockey Club.

[18][19] Prior to the January 23, 1924 game against the Boston Athletic Association, Wesminsters manager Charles Van Norman informed USAHA president William S. Haddock that the team would not take the ice unless they received certificates of standing for Canadian players they wanted to add to the roster.

[22][23] On January 30, Sullivan and Van Norman announced they were leaving the Westminster Hockey Club, citing not the team's expulsion, but rather the arrest of two players (Normand Shay and Lorn Armstrong), as the reason for their departure.

[28] That same offseason, the St. Nicholas Hockey Club of New York City withdrew from the league, leaving New Haven as the only non-Boston team in the eastern group.