Written alongside producers Dr. Luke and Chopsquad DJ, it was sent to rhythmic contemporary radio as the album's fifth single on July 28, 2020.
[3] Felson Sajonas of Hypebeast noted "Wishing Well" for being a metaphor for Juice's "deep desire to be free from his demons and the constant cycle of drugs and depression".
[7] Billboard ranked the song as the best on Legends Never Die, with the magazine's Michael Saponara regarding it as "a bonafide stand-out cut with Juice putting his gifts on display".
[1] Variety's Jem Aswad named it one of the top songs of the week, noting its "unintentionally timely" opening line: "I can't breathe".
A variety of emojis acts as his emotions, while scenes cut to an army of ants, Juice gazing into the stars on top of his convertible, and living an extravagant lifestyle at his mansion.