[1] The 'Wasps' of Yonkers defeated the 'Black and White Brigade' of Hollywood Inn 3–0 to win the tournament.
The association became the USFA[2] and awarded the Dewar Trophy for the 1913 edition of the AAFA cup.
[3] The Dewar Trophy was also awarded to the National Challenge Cup winners beginning in the 1913–14 season.
NYSL- New York State Amateur LeagueMDL- Metropolitan and District Amateur Foot Ball LeagueNAFBL- National Association Foot Ball League The first round was played on October 27, 1912.
Anglo-Saxon, Clan MacDuff, Critchley, German, Hollywood Inn, New York Celtic, Washington, and White Rose had first round byes.