[5] Before joining Gimlet, Vogt and Goldman hosted a technology and culture podcast called TLDR for WNYC.

[8] Producers of Reply All included Phia Bennin, Tim Howard, Damiano Marchetti, Anna Foley, Jessica Yung, Lisa Wang, and formerly Sruthi Pinnamaneni.

[11] In early 2021, the podcast began releasing a series of episodes called "The Test Kitchen", which covered allegations of a racist and toxic work environment at the food magazine Bon Appétit.

[14] On May 18, 2022, it was announced that hosts Dzotsi and Goldman were leaving the show and the current iteration of Reply All would end on June 23, 2022.

The nomination cited its unusual social media presence, including an event where the hosts accepted phone calls from listeners for 48 hours straight.

"[23] In 2017, it was announced that director Richard Linklater would direct a movie about American quack physician John R. Brinkley, to star Robert Downey Jr., based on the 2017 Reply All episode "Man of the People".

[28] The New York Times reported that the number of overall listeners to the show increased 35 percent across platforms in the days after its release.