The club was established in 1929 as Alvechurch Juniors and played in the Redditch League until World War II.

[4][5] In 1965–66 they reached the semi-finals of the FA Amateur Cup, eventually losing 1–0 to Wealdstone at Stamford Bridge with around 10,000 supporters travelling to London for the game.

[5] The season also saw them make FA Cup history; in the fourth qualifying round they were drawn against Oxford City.

[7] The win meant that Alvechurch reached the first round proper for the first time, also becoming the first club from the Midland Combination to do so.

[4] The club's first season in the league saw them reach the first round of the FA Cup again, in which they defeated Fourth Division Exeter City 1–0.

[6] The club was re-established under the name Alvechurch Villa in 1994,[3] entering the Premier Division of the Midland Combination.

[10] In 2002–03 the club were Premier Division champions and League Cup winners,[5] and were promoted to the Midland Alliance.

The club then purchased a field on Redditch Road for £1,000, building a new ground that became opened in 1957 and was named Lye Meadow.

[3] A record attendance of 13,500 was set for an FA Amateur Cup quarter-final tie against Enfield in 1964–65, although it is estimated that there were up to 16,000 in the ground.