Tiller played guard at Central Islip Senior High School, where he graduated.

In 2006, Tiller won Newsday's Zellner Award for being the best lineman in Suffolk County.

During the 2010 season, Tiller played in all 13 games and made notable contributions to the Orange football team.

[1] Tiller was selected in the sixth round, 179th overall, by the New Orleans Saints in the 2012 NFL draft.

Tiller was signed to the practice squad of the Green Bay Packers on November 20, 2013.

In the middle of the season, he was signed to the 53-man roster and played two games alternating snaps with Jordan Devey.