This coincided with an unbeaten start to their Women's Premier League campaign.

[1][3] Owing to renovations, they were unable to use Ballymena Showgrounds for a number of home matches and were only being offered a "disgraceful and embarrassing" pitch in a local park as a replacement.

[1] In the following years, Ballymena United Allstars often finished in mid-table in the Women's Premier League.

In 2005, they reached the semi-finals of the IFA Women's Challenge Cup but lost 2–0 to Northland Raiders F.C.

[4] In 2012, they made the final of the Premier League Cup however they lost 2–0 to Glentoran Belfast United.