It is currently anchored by Barnes & Noble, Kohl's, Total Wine & More, and Target along with one of the Milwaukee area's two Apple Stores.

In February in preparation of the next redevelopment, some stores began to move to new locations in the mall.

[4] In 1974, Bayshore was converted into an indoor mall with 500,000-square-feet of retail space which added many new stores including Kohl's as the fourth anchor.

Sports Authority, iPic Theaters, and Barnes & Noble were added as anchors.

Many new stores would move into Bayshore like Trader Joe's, California Pizza Kitchen, J.Crew, Apple, and The Cheesecake Factory.

[6] The indoor portion of the mall was closed and demolished and construction has started on the apartments.

[7] In 2023 a parking garage in Bayshore Mall located on the west end collapsed.