Services began in a large stone church on Avenue Road, with approximately 112 people in attendance.

G Robert Gray was Senior Pastor serving alongside Dr. Tozer from 1959 to 1962 before leaving to found Brimley Rd Alliance Church in Scarborough.

He returned to Bayview Glen Church in 1992–1993 on an interim basis after his successor Arnold Reimer's resignation.

Arnold Reimer (1970–1991) helped to relocate the congregation from Avenue Road Church to its present location.

Annan's tenure in Bayview Glen included the creation of a third service ("Higher Ground") that in the gymnasium that features a cooked breakfast, and the facilities of the church were made available for more conventions and fellowship gatherings.

He resigned at the end of April 2006 and was accepted as a Senior Pastor in Harvest Hills Alliance Church, Calgary, Alberta.

As of July 2024[update] the pastoral team includes Terry Sanderson, Sawyer Bullock, Dave Lewis, Beverley Deguire, Min-Soo Kang and Sean Luellwitz.

[1] After Lucas Cooper left the church in early 2021, the search committee hired Terry Sanderson in mid 2022.