The mall features Boscov's, Dick's Sporting Goods, JCPenney, Rural King, and a U-Haul storage center.

In 1970, the Beaver Valley Mall opened with The Joseph Horne Company, Gimbels, and Sears as the original anchors.

After the move to the mall, the original Kaufmann's location in nearby Rochester was subdivided into a Giant Eagle and a Kmart.

The Joseph Horne Company (owned by the New York City based Associated Dry Goods Corporation) operated in the Beaver Valley Mall until 1995.

In 1995, Federated Department Stores acquired Horne's and renamed all former locations under its own Lazarus regional nameplate.

In 1998, after operating a few years as Lazarus, Federated closed several locations including the Beaver Valley Mall store.