Murphy store and quickly spread through most of the original section of the mall, which did not have fire sprinklers.

The first phase, beginning in 1995, started with a new store, Kaufmann's, which was added to the far end of the mall to replace the then-vacant Hess's.

[10] Phase two consisted of opening a new three-story parking garage and a new eight-screen Carmike Cinema.

Federated proceeded to convert various May properties to Macy's, including the Logan Valley Mall store.

On July 7, 2021, it was announced that the AMC CLASSIC Logan Valley 8 had closed permanently, which was attributed to the COVID-19 pandemic.