[2] Later expansions brought Sears and JCPenney as anchors, as well as regional department store chain J.M.

In 2003, J. Herzog & Sons bought the mall from the Richard E. Jacobs group, which had put it up for sale in 1999.

On February 1, 2023, it was announced that Dillard's would be closing its location at the mall leaving it with only Best Buy as the remaining anchor.

The company announced a $250 million redevelopment plan for the site, to be renamed Conestoga Marketplace, which involves tearing down much of the mall including the vacant anchor stores (but retaining the Best Buy location), converting the remaining inline mall space into outside-facing retail space and building a new Target store as an anchor.

[9] The final remaining interior corridor closed on May 9, 2024, as tenants relocated to the new outside-facing retail space.