The current structure was built in 1872 in the Gothic Revival style, as the fourth building for the congregation on the site.

[3] It was described as an 1872 newcomer, a whitewashed eccentricity with unmatching towers, an unexpected rose window and, within, amen pews flanking the pulpit.

[7] The choir The Master Singers of Westchester performed regular concerts such as Britten's A Ceremony of Carols in 1984,[8] his cantata St. Nicholas in 1986,[9] and Bach's Mass in B minor in March 2003.

The members of the congregation work with Habitat for Humanity, the Mount Kisco Interfaith Food Pantry, and Midnight Run.

• Ruth Graham, "For Christmas, Pastors Offer Comfort and Joy in a Somber Season," New York Times.