The school moved from Belfry in 2005 to a new site 3 miles north near the West Virginia border in Goody, Kentucky.

The new Belfry High School's campus consisted of a main building and an athletic complex.

[citation needed] The Pirate football team has been a source of pride for the community for many years.

In his second season, the Pirates would make another run to the 3A state championship game, falling to Paducah Tilghman 29–14.

[4] Following the 2021 season, running back Isaac Dixon was named Kentucky Mr. Football, becoming the first, and only, Pirate to take home the honor.