In 2008, the boys' soccer team again won the Class A State title, and the cheerleading squad placed first at the Jamfest National Championship Competition.

Brother David, the founder of this religious order, provided the school, which was staffed by Sisters Harriet Gardiner, Polly Beavin and Nancy Lynd.

Bethlehem was operated exclusively as a parish high school for girls, no longer owned by the Sisters, but staffed by them.

Bethlehem is the only Roman Catholic high school in the Archdiocese of Louisville outside of Jefferson County.

Bethlehem High School has a variety of extracurricular activities in sports and non-athletic areas, including drama, speech, National Honor Society, Spirit Club, choir, student council, golf, and cross country.