[6][7] In September 1954, the Butler district notified its eight sending communities that growing enrollment of borough residents would mean that there would be no space available at Butler High School and that the local districts serving students from Passaic County communities and Pequannock Township would have to make alternate arrangements by 1958.

[11] The gymnasium was unusable due to water damage caused during the fighting of the fire and physical education classes were held outside for the remainder of the school year.

Band and choir room, auditorium, foreign language, history, mathematics, and English classrooms, and science laboratories.

The team was the Group II co-champion in 1978 after a 1–1 tie in the finals against the two-time defending champion Haddonfield Memorial High School.

[28] The team won the 1994 North II Group I title with a 35–21 victory in the championship game against New Providence High School.

[30][31][32] The girls' basketball team won the 2003 North II Group I championship, defeating runner-up Glen Ridge High School 65–39.

[33] The team moved on to the Group I state championship, defeating Wildwood High School by 43–37 in the final.

[34][35] The girls' soccer team won the 2002 North I Group I state sectional championship over Glen Ridge High School by a score of 2–1.

[37] The team won the sectional state championship again in 2005, with a 3–0 win over Midland Park High School.