[1] He played cornerback and wide receiver for the Cardinal football team and had 1,396 all-purpose yards and 19 touchdowns as a senior.

[5] Sutton started in all 12 games as a true freshman in 2013 and recorded 39 tackles, two interceptions, one sack, and a touchdown.

[10] Sutton received an invitation to the Senior Bowl and raised his draft stock after impressing scouts during practice and showing versatility and willingness for playing both safety and cornerback during the game.

[18] He entered training camp competing with William Gay, Coty Sensabaugh, and Mike Hilton for a backup cornerback position.

[22] On December 4, 2017, Sutton made his professional regular season debut after he replaced Coty Sensabaugh at left cornerback in the second half against the Cincinnati Bengals.

Sutton held Green to no catches and deflected a pass to help the Steelers overcome a 17-point deficit and defeat the Bengals 23–20.

[24] On December 17, 2017, he earned his first career start in place of Joe Haden, who was still recovering from a fractured fibula sustained in Week 10.

[26] He finished his rookie season with five combined tackles (four solo) and a pass deflection in five games and one start.

[30] Sutton's snaps would be diminished until Week 13 in a 17–10 win against the eventual Super Bowl Champion New England Patriots.

[33] In a Week 6 prime time game against the Los Angeles Chargers, Sutton Intercepted a pass off Philip Rivers and returned it for 26 yards to secure the victory.

[34] During the Steelers' 21–7 loss against the Cleveland Browns in Week 10, Sutton had a sack and returned his first punt of the season for eight yards.

[37] In Week 6 against the Browns, Sutton recorded his first interception of the season off a pass thrown by Baker Mayfield during the 38–7 win.

[38] He finished the 2020 season with one sack, 30 total tackles (27 solo), one interception, eight passes defended, and three forced fumbles.

[50] This resulted in the Detroit Lions cutting Sutton on March 21, 2024, after failing to turn himself into the police after two weeks.