It was decided that the first year classes would be held in the vacated St. Hubert's School in South Windsor (now occupied by Monseigneur Jean Noel).

However, after further evaluation, the WECDSB decided to purchase an 11-acre property between Ouellette and McDougall Avenue to speed up the construction process.

On January 28, 2020, the WECDSB approved a recommendation to hire +VG Architects to design the new school, which would accommodate the estimated 900 students and incorporate modern educational practices.

On March 16, 2021, the WECDSB's board of trustees passed a motion approving Oscar Construction Company Ltd. to build the new school.

[5] On January 9, 2023, the new $30 million Catholic Central High School building opened to staff.

At the Junior and Freshman levels, 12 times Catholic Central players were selected as WECSSAA MVPs.