They are currently members of the Peterborough & District League Premier Division and play at West Street.

In 1936 they reformed as a junior team, and joined Division 1B of the Cambridgeshire League, winning it at the first attempt.

The club set its record attendance of 2,000 in a match against local rivals March Town United at the end of the 1988–89 season,[2] a game which March Town United needed to win to clinch the ECL title (and did following a 5–0 win).

When the league added a second tier in 1988, Chatteris were placed in the Premier Division following a 7th-place finish the previous season.

However, the club were eventually relegated in 1995 after finishing bottom and winning just two league games all season.

In 2008 they transferred to Senior Division B the Cambridgeshire League, finishing third in their first season and earning promotion.