[2] The CNU Men's basketball team holds an impressive .683 percent victory percentage (as of the end of the 2021-22 season) and 16 All-American Athlete honors over its almost 60 years of existence.

In 2023, the Captains won their first Men's D-III National Championship over Mount Union with a last second, buzzer-beater layup by junior Trey Barber, 74–72.

[4] The Women's basketball team, started in 1971, sports an overall win percentage at .669 (as of the end of the 2021-22 season) and has fielded 7 All-American Athlete honors.

In 2013, the team reached the Final Four in the NCAA Division III National Tournament, the Elite Eight in 2006, and the Sweet Sixteen a total of six times.

Started in 2001 under head coach Matt Kelchner, the team made it to the NCAA play-offs 10 times between 2001 and 2014.

[9] The CNU women's lacrosse team was founded in 2001, and has made the D-III tournament a total of eight times as of 2022, advancing as far as the Sweet Sixteen in 2013.

The team players had several wins over Division I opponents and sophomore Eddie Glidewell finished in the Top 35 in the Nation.

He joined five other players to reach this distinction - Holden Knight, Detlef Schultz, Jason Martin, and Hugh Spain.

[14][15] The CNU women's volleyball team was established in 1977, and has enjoyed considerable success in recent years under head coach Lindsay Birch.

[16] CNU sports club programs include ice hockey,[17] equestrian, dressage, cycling, fishing, lacrosse, martial arts,[18] rock climbing, rugby, scuba diving, silver storm dance, soccer, swimming, table tennis, tennis, ultimate frisbee and volleyball.

It was started by Phill Condrey (President), Steven Mohn (Vice-President), Jason Semko (Secretary), Scott Siclari (Treasurer), and Jeremy Wells.

CNU MAC is a competitive mixed martial arts team that trains in Brazilian jiu-jitsu, wrestling, kickboxing and Muay Thai.

CNUMAC CNU Men's Volleyball club holds practices 3 days a week, and attends at least 3 tournaments a semester.