It was anchored by EFO Furniture, Planet Fitness, Dunham's Sports, MVP Clubhouse, and a VA Clinic.

[12][13][14] After the closure of Ames in 2002, the vacant store was used occasionally for the Animal Resource Center Yard Sale, Eagle Arms Gun Show, and WNEP Outdoor Expo.

[1] Non-retail office space leases at the mall started in the early 2010s and included Geisinger Health Plan.

[14] Cedar sold the mall in April 2013 for $2.8 million to Empire Columbia LP and management was replaced.

[9][41] Columbia Colonnade during 2021 suffered from drinking water issues, heating/cooling problems, lack of staff including security, and roof leaks.

[42] Columbia Colonnade was originally scheduled to be auctioned in July 2022 with a starting bid of $3.4 million, but that was later delayed until August.

[44] After multiple failed attempts to auction off the property, the owner, Foust Development, decided to try and revive the mall.

In addition to the Arby's being built on one of the mall's lots, Foust hopes to attract interest from Jersey Mike's Subs or Primanti Bros.[45]