[2] Craghead United entered the FA Cup for the first time in the 1907–08 season, but were defeated in the preliminary round by Leadgate Park.
The club enjoyed their best run in the Cup during the 1909–10 campaign, defeating Crook Town and Stanley United before losing to Seaham Harbour in the third qualifying round.
Craghead United were knocked out in the second qualifying round on two occasions, but generally struggled to progress past the preliminary stage.
[3] Despite being an amateur team, Craghead United were represented by several players who also played professional football.
Harry Pringle and Jack Small, who both went on to play in the Football League, both started their careers with Craghead United.