[2][3] As a true freshman at Michigan in 2019, Hill played in 13 games with three starts and had 36 tackles and one interception.
[11] Hill was eased into his rookie year by Bengals defensive coordinator Lou Anarumo, backing up Jessie Bates at free safety, and playing as a gunner on special teams snaps alongside Stanley Morgan.
In Week 15 against the Tampa Bay Buccaneers, Hill would play his first game as a starter, switching positions to cornerback due to both regular starter Mike Hilton and backup Jalen Davis suffering injuries the week prior.
[13] During the Bengals' Week 1 loss against the Cleveland Browns, Hill recorded his first career interception off of quarterback Deshaun Watson.
[16] Following preseason, it was announced that Hill had beat out DJ Turner for the starting cornerback role.