[10] The band went on to record a five-song demo EP at The Jam Room in Columbia, South Carolina and then met music producer Ricky Rodriguez after playing a local See You at the Pole event.

[13][12] After the band self-released the album and EP[12] and a few years time, Rodriguez was able to catch the attention of Flicker Records founders Mark Stuart and Will McGinniss (of Audio Adrenaline).

[18][19][20][21] Following the release of the album, the group appeared at ShoutFest '06,[22] gained exposure on MTVU,[23] and had success at Christian rock radio with the single "MySpace"; their profile on said website became very popular as a result.

[20][26] A month prior to the album's release, Flicker Records was bought by Provident Label Group, a Sony/BMG subsidiary.

[36][37][38] The festival headliners included other bands such as New Found Glory, Zebrahead, Rancid, 311, Angels & Airwaves, and Allister.

[40] In 2009, after a potential label deal with Gotee Records did not consolidate,[40] the band independently released their third album Adventures in Eville.

[40] Sony BMG proceeded to release the album internationally in Japan and the band made another venture over to play in Punkspring '10.

[43] The song was themed as a satirical parody based on the 2008 film Twilight, and more specifically, the main character of Edward Cullen.

[43] In mid-2010, bassist Caleb Satterfield decided to leave the band to focus on his marriage and lead a life away from touring.

The Japanese edition of Sugarfist contained all six songs from Quota EP plus three more bonus tracks as well, making it in its entirety, a sixteen-track album.

[49] The next day, Matt Langston proceeded to post the first song off the EP, an electronic cover of the hymn "Turn Your Eyes," on Eleventyseven's SoundCloud account.

[6] Lead singer Matt Langston wrote a farewell statement on the band's official Facebook page stating where all the members were at this time and what they are planning to be working on in the near future.

On November 26, 2016, lead singer Matt Langston and Bassist Davey Davenport posted a vlog announcement on the band's official Facebook page.

[7] In the vlog, they stated that Eleventyseven had returned with a new podcast entitled Eleventylife in which the band's origins and lifespan until its death would be discussed.

Guest stars over the show's run have included Mallory Graham and Scott Tyler of The Rough and Tumble[62] and Wavorly bassist Matt Lott.

[65][66] In August, 2018, Matt Langston debuted a re-envisioned version of "Appalachian Wine" off the band's Attack of the Mountain Medley EP and stated it was planned to be on the B-Sides companion release to Rad Science.

[68] On October 4 & 11, 2019, Matt Langston released an interview with Brendan Brown of Wheatus on the Eleventylife podcast[69] and debuted Eleventyseven's cover of "Teenage Dirtbag".

[77] On June 6, 2023, the band announced that the upcoming single "Side Hug" would be part of their seventh studio album.

They are commonly coupled with other Christian punk artists from their genre such as Relient K, Stellar Kart, Hawk Nelson, Philmont, and Capital Lights.

The project has currently released two full-length albums (Heta Himlen and Bang & Whimper), two EPs (The Jellyrox and Embellish), and a few singles.

[88] In 2016, Matt Langston joined Five Iron Frenzy founding members Leanor Ortega Till (also known as "Jeff the Girl"), Scott Kerr, and Andrew Verdecchio to create a power pop EDM band entitled The Fast Feeling.

[91][92][93] In October 2016, the debut song "Break" from Pulses was included in Indie Vision Music's compilation release Hearts Bleed Passion Vol.

Langston also teamed up with Rob Johnson of The Switch Kids to form a small side-project called Best Friend Fight which officially released one song, "Walking Dead Apocalypse".

[99] In 2022, Langston reunited with former The Fast Feeling bandmate Scott Kerr of Five Iron Frenzy to form an indie pop band called Fantasy League.