[14] On June 27, 2018, Nadler announced the release of her eighth studio album, along with the title track which features a collaboration by Angel Olsen.

[16] On September 10, 2018, the third single "I Can't Listen to Gene Clark Anymore" was released, which features a collaboration by American actress and musician Sharon van Etten.

"[4] Liz Ikowsky from Albumism said: "Written in response to the emotional strain of being a touring musician, For My Crimes feels therapeutic and apologetic.

She also noted the songs on the album "reflect a person being confronted with the truth and grieving the mistakes made along the way.

"[6] David Sackllah from Consequence of Sound said the album "is a shining example of how Nadler continues to impress and improve upon each release.