The organization's mission was to "end poverty and hunger, promote good health and well-being, and foster employment opportunities and economic growth in ways that exemplify humanist values.
[5] The organization's founder Dale McGowan originally envisioned it as a way for nonreligious people and humanists to give to charity by "passing the tithing plate."
[6] In March 2011, the organization responded to the 2011 Tōhoku earthquake and tsunami by launching a disaster response program, raising and distributing $20,000 for recovery.
[8] The American Cancer Society was criticized in 2011 for turning down participation from Foundation Beyond Belief in its Relay For Life "National Team" program.
[17] Through 2020, FBB gave the CIG one quarter per year to various anti-poverty organizations that met high standards of innovation, inclusiveness, data, and cultural sensitivity.
[19] Rebranded player jerseys were auctioned off during the games[20] and a shoe drive benefiting Soles4Souls was incorporated into 2015 the event (promoted as "Leave Your Soles at the Gate").
The team beat the Winnipeg Goldeyes in 2015 7–4 in front of 8,500 fans at CHS Field bringing the Aints' record to 2 wins and 2 losses.
An email to donors stated "We have met with an insurmountable financial crisis combined with liabilities that have led us to this very hard decision.
Each fiscal quarter through 2020, FBB selected four organizations to support, in the categories of Poverty and Health, Human Rights, Education, and Natural World.
Over the course of a year, the team worked with several organizations across the world, including in Cambodia, Uganda, Ghana, Haiti, Ecuador, Colombia, and Guatemala.