[4][5] After the league successes the club made its debut in the FA Cup in the 1911–12 season, reaching the fifth qualifying round before losing 4–1 to Southport Central.

The 1954–55 season saw the club reach the first round of the FA Cup, where they were defeated by Football League side Leyton Orient in front of a record crowd of 8,000.

In the 2003–04 campaign the club gained media attention when they asked local white witch Titania Hardie, to help improve their home form as they struggled at Badgers Hill.

In 2019, When reviewing the current club crest, Frome Town FC agreed that the design was too detailed and didn't display well on colour and image backgrounds with digital files no longer accessible, and changed logo.

In the 2023–24 season they reached the 3rd round of the FA Trophy the furthest they have gone in the competition after beating Worthing 4–3 on penalties after a 2–2 draw at Badgers Hill Note: Flags indicate national team as defined under FIFA eligibility rules; some limited exceptions apply.

In 2012 the club added a new 250 seater stand to the stadium, so that their ground would meet the requirements set out for the Southern Football League Premier Division.