They are currently members of the Southern League Division One Central and play at Hertingfordbury Park.

[7] Despite their poor performance, the club were placed in the Premier Division the following season, but went on to finish bottom of the table again.

The 1962–63 season was abandoned due to bad weather, but Hertford won both the League Cup and the Eastern Section of the emergency competition, going on to lose the title decider to Western Section Champions Edmonton 5–2 on aggregate.

[8][10] They also won the East Anglian Cup by beating Boston United 1–0 in the final, a match played at home in front of a 3,000 crowd.

A fourth-place finish in 1963–64 was enough to earn promotion to Division One at the first attempt and the club went on to win the league's Memorial Shield in 1967–68.

[11] At the end of the 2020–21 season, which was curtailed due to the COVID-19 pandemic, they were transferred to Division One Central of the Southern League.

Although it was extended the following year, when a covered terrace was also built at the car park end of the ground,[12] it was later demolished.