It is part of the Elwood School District in Huntington, New York.
Cuba Hill School was built in 1955 as a replacement to Elwood's aging Little Red Schoolhouse (formally called Elwood School), which opened in 1903 and still stands abandoned on Cuba Hill Road to this day.
[1] At that point the school comprised solely what is today the third and fourth grade wing.
An annex to the school was constructed as a standalone building in the mid-1960s, and today serves as the fifth grade wing.
[2][3] The two formerly separate buildings were connected in 2001 with the addition of a new auditorium.