[1] In 2022, Hibbert began attending the University of Connecticut, where he played for the men's soccer team.
[5][6] In January 2024, he signed a professional contract with their second team, Atlanta United 2, in MLS Next Pro.
[9][10] He made his debut for Birmingham on June 19, posting a clean sheet in a 3-0 victory over San Antonio FC.
[12][13] Hibbert is eligible to represent the United States an Jamaica at international level.
In March 2024, he was called up to the Jamaica national team for a pair of friendlies against Trinidad and Tobago.