[2] Coleman Catholic was a member of the Mid-Hudson Athletic League (MHAL) and competed in Division 4 along with the high schools of Millbrook, Rhinebeck, and Webutuck.

Other MHAL member schools are Dover, Ellenville, Highland, Hyde Park, Marlboro, New Paltz, Onteora, Pine Plains, Red Hook, Rondout Valley, Saugerties, Spackenkill and Wallkill.

The MHAL is within Section 9 the New York State Public High School Athletic Association (NYSPHSAA).

Kingston Daily Freeman Player of the year Ryan Johnson 2005 Coleman Catholic was the only Class D team in the MHAL.

The Coleman student-actors were then taken on a tour of set, the backstage, and technical workings of the Majestic Theater.